The honest comparison
Where to land
First, what staying costs, so the alternatives have something to be measured against. On a typical US order, Etsy takes a $0.20 listing fee, a 6.5% transaction fee charged on the price plus shipping, and 3% + $0.25 payment processing: roughly 10.8% of the order before ads. If Offsite Ads sells your item, add 15%, or 12% if your shop has ever crossed $10,000 in a year, a rate that then applies for the life of the shop.
Every lane below trades differently. Marketplaces bring traffic and take a bigger cut. Your own storefront takes a smaller cut and brings nobody. That trade, not the fee table alone, is the decision.
| Lane | Cost to run | Cut per sale | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shopify | $39/mo Basic ($29/mo billed yearly) | 2.9% + 30¢ via Shopify Payments | Your own storefront, physical and digital, room to grow |
| Payhip | $0 Free plan | 5% (2% on $29/mo Plus, 0% on $99/mo Pro) | Digital downloads: patterns, printables, STL files, ebooks |
| Big Cartel | $0 / $15 / $30 per mo | No platform fee; processor fees only | Small physical catalogs, artists and makers |
| eBay | No shop needed | 13.6% + $0.30–$0.40 per order, most categories | Built-in traffic, vintage, collectibles, almost anything |
| Amazon Handmade | Application required; the $39.99/mo Professional fee is charged for the first month, then waived for Handmade | 15% referral fee | Handmade sellers who want Amazon's traffic |
| Ko-fi Shop | $0, or $12/mo Gold | 5% free tier, 0% on Gold; processor fees apply | Creators who already have an audience somewhere |
| Folksy | £0 pay-as-you-go, or £7.50/mo Plus (UK) | 15p listing + 6% commission, plus VAT | UK-based handmade sellers only |
Fees as published by each platform and checked November 17, 2026. Payment processing is included where the platform bundles it and noted where it is separate. Confirm on the platform's pricing page before you commit; fees change.
The lanes, one by one
Shopify — your own store, your own rules
The landing spot most Etsy sellers name first. You get a real storefront on your own domain, no marketplace rules about what your photos may train, and every tool imaginable. The catches are the monthly bill, the 2% surcharge if you use a payment gateway other than Shopify Payments, and the big one: Shopify sends you no shoppers. Traffic is your job, through search, social, and the audience you brought with you. Best for sellers with repeat buyers and any following at all.
Payhip — built for digital downloads
If you sell files (patterns, printables, SVGs, STLs, ebooks), Payhip is the simplest move in this list: free to start at 5%, every feature on every plan, and it delivers your files and handles the storefront. It pays out through your own Stripe or PayPal. And the detail that matters this month: we read Payhip's Terms of Use in full, and they contain no AI-training clause at all. The license you grant Payhip covers delivering your files to buyers and can be ended by deleting the file, the opposite shape from Etsy's new perpetual grant. Two honest caveats: those terms were last updated in 2018, so they predate the AI era rather than taking a stand on it; this read covered the Terms of Use, not Payhip's Privacy Policy; and Payhip brings little traffic of its own.
Big Cartel — the small-shop lane
Made for independent artists and makers with modest catalogs: a free tier, paid tiers at $15 and $30, and no platform transaction fee at all; you pay only your Stripe or PayPal processing. Tiers are built around catalog size (5 products on the free tier, then 50, then 500), with features layered on as you climb; the free tier is a toe in the water, not a shop. Fewer power features than Shopify, and like all storefronts, no built-in traffic. For a small physical catalog, the math is the friendliest on this page.
eBay — the traffic is real, so is the cut
The one marketplace here with Etsy-scale buyer traffic, and a final value fee of 13.6% plus a per-order fee in most categories. Payments are handled inside eBay. It suits vintage, collectibles, supplies, and anything people search for by name. It is a poor home for a brand you are trying to build, and fees vary by category, so check yours before listing.
Amazon Handmade — biggest river, strictest banks
A 15% referral fee buys access to Amazon's shoppers, but entry is by application, products must be genuinely handmade under Amazon's definitions, and you operate entirely on Amazon's terms, inside Amazon's house style. Some sellers thrive there. Nobody would call it owning your shop.
Ko-fi Shop — for sellers whose audience is the storefront
Ko-fi takes 5% on the free tier and nothing on Gold, and money lands directly in your own Stripe or PayPal. It handles physical and digital. It is not a marketplace in any meaningful sense; it is a checkout for people who already follow you. If your buyers come from your socials, that may be all you need, at the lowest cost here.
Folksy — UK sellers only
A genuinely handmade marketplace with gentle fees (15p listings, 6% commission, both plus VAT; a £7.50/mo Plus plan for volume). It is restricted to sellers based in the UK, which settles the question for everyone else.
Picking, in one paragraph
Sell files? Start at Payhip. Sell physical goods and have any audience of your own? Shopify if you want the full store, Big Cartel if the catalog is small and the budget smaller. Need a marketplace's traffic more than you need control? eBay for breadth, Amazon Handmade if you qualify and accept the rules, Folksy if you are UK-based. Plenty of sellers run two: a marketplace for discovery and a storefront for repeat buyers, with the storefront's address in every package.