The part nobody explains until it bites
Getting paid, off Etsy
On Etsy, payments were invisible: Etsy Payments took the money, held it on Etsy's schedule, and deposited what was left. On your own storefront, you choose the processor, and the differences are real money and real timing. Here is the landscape, with the fees each provider publishes.
| Provider | Standard online fee (US) | When money lands | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stripe | 2.9% + 30¢ per charge | First payout 7–14 days; then about 2 business days | $15 dispute fee, plus $15 to counter (refunded if you win) |
| PayPal | 3.49% + 49¢ (PayPal Checkout); 2.99% + 49¢ for standard card processing | Balance is immediate in PayPal; instant transfer to bank costs 1.5% | $20 chargeback fee, $15 dispute fee; new-seller holds are common |
| Shop Pay | Not a processor: it rides on Shopify Payments at your Shopify rate | Follows your Shopify Payments schedule, typically 3–5 business days in the US | Only exists inside Shopify checkout; it is a faster checkout button, not an account |
| Square | 3.3% + 30¢ online on the free plan (2.9% + 30¢ sits behind the $49/mo Plus plan) | Next business day, free | The headline rate most people remember is the paid-plan rate |
Standard published US rates, checked November 17, 2026 on each provider's pricing pages. Your rate can differ by plan, volume, and how the payment is taken. Confirm before you build on a number.
What changes when the marketplace stops holding your money
- You are the merchant now. Chargebacks come to you, with fees, and you supply the evidence. Keep shipping confirmations and delivery scans; they are your defense.
- New accounts get held. Every processor protects itself against brand-new sellers: first payouts delayed a week or two, and reserves or holds if sales spike suddenly. A launch announcement that works can look, to a risk algorithm, like fraud. Open the account early, verify everything they ask for, and make your first sales small and boring.
- Payout timing is a cash-flow fact. Materials for order two may need buying before order one's money lands. Know your schedule before a big restock.
- Your platform may pick for you. Shopify steers you to Shopify Payments (outside gateways cost an extra 2% on Basic). Payhip and Ko-fi pay through your own Stripe or PayPal. Big Cartel works with Stripe and PayPal. eBay and Amazon run their own payments entirely; there is nothing to choose.
Which one, in one paragraph
Most departing Etsy sellers end up on Stripe, directly or through Shopify Payments, because it is the default everywhere and the rate is the reference rate. PayPal earns its place as a second button: some buyers trust it and will not check out without it, even at a higher fee. Square makes sense if you also sell in person at markets and want one system for both. Shop Pay is not a choice so much as a feature: if you are on Shopify, turn it on, because stored-payment checkouts convert better, and it costs nothing beyond your normal Shopify Payments rate.
The fee comparison that actually matters
On a $40 order, Stripe's 2.9% + 30¢ takes $1.46. Etsy's combined take on the same order, before ads, was roughly $4.30. Sellers leaving over the terms usually find the money got better on their own storefront; what got worse is everything Etsy bundled invisibly: traffic, trust, and a payments department. Budget your time for those, not your margin for fees.